Engaging with your audience may be more powerful than most social media teams realise. A new data study from Buffer has revealed that responding to comments on social media posts can drive a 5% to 42% increase in engagement, depending on the platform.
The findings come from an analysis of nearly two million posts across more than 220,000 accounts, examining performance on Threads, LinkedIn, Instagram, Facebook, X (formerly Twitter) and Bluesky. The study compared each account’s posts over time to measure how engagement changed on posts where creators or brands replied to comments versus those where they didn’t.
The results were consistent: posts where brands or creators participated in the comments regularly outperformed those where they did not, lending data-driven weight to the long-standing advice that the best way to get engagement is to be engaging.
Engagement lift by platform
| Platform | Engagement Increase |
|---|---|
| Threads | +42% |
| +30% | |
| +21% | |
| +9% | |
| X (Twitter) | +8% |
| Bluesky | +5% |
Threads delivers the highest lift
Funnily enough, the biggest impact was found on the newest platform, Threads, where engagement jumped by 42% on posts with active comment replies. The platform’s conversational design – where replies play a central role in the feed – appears to reward dialogue more heavily than other networks.
Proven results on LinkedIn and Instagram
LinkedIn came in second with a 30% increase, highlighting the value of two-way interaction in professional networking. Instagram followed with a 21% lift, reinforcing that responding to comments can boost visibility and performance even in highly visual environments.
Smaller but meaningful gains on Facebook, X and Bluesky
Facebook showed a 9% lift, which may seem modest but is significant given the platform’s scale and maturity. X posts with replies saw an 8% boost, though the sample size was smaller. Bluesky, still relatively new, recorded a 5% increase, suggesting the pattern holds even in emerging networks.
Why the effect matters
The findings suggest that replying to comments does more than nurture community sentiment – it likely signals meaningful engagement to platform algorithms, increasing reach and reactions. While the study stops short of declaring causation, the consistency across platforms indicates a strong behavioural pattern: active interaction encourages more participation.
Importantly, the research compared engagement within the same account rather than comparing different creators, helping isolate the effect to the action of replying rather than account size or popularity.
Human connection always wins
The takeaway is refreshingly simple: engagement drives engagement. Responding to audience interactions isn’t a trick – it’s a fundamental component of relationship-building on social media. The study reinforces the idea that participating in conversation, rather than broadcasting content into the void, remains one of the most reliable ways to grow.
It’s the second week of November, and Black Friday promotions are in full swing; emails, ads, organic posts. But, how many of these promotions are you actually paying [...]
Google’s new search feature, AI Overviews, has recently launched in Australia, transforming how we interact with search engines. With AI-generated summaries now appearing directly in search engine [...]
TikTok can be polarising. Those who use it, love it. Those who don’t often find it confusing or aren’t sure how it could fit into their social media [...]
We’ve been geeking out over our latest Audience Intelligence Reports which rolled out to our clients over the last two weeks. Separate from our monthly digital marketing [...]
When you think about it, Pinterest is not really a social media platform but more of a search engine. While it does allow users to follow and [...]
When a social media post starts gaining traction, you’ll often receive prompts from the platform encouraging you to reach a wider audience by boosting the post. A [...]
In our last article, we explored the rise of zero-click searches and its impact on how we find information online. This shift in user behaviour has also [...]
One of our biggest takeaways from State of Social 2024 was the evolution of zero-click searches and the impact it will have on the way we do [...]
Have you noticed a drop in engagement on your brand’s Instagram posts? Likes not flowing as much as what they used to? The good news is you’re [...]
Did you know that after approximately 4 exposures to your ad, your conversions can drop by almost half? As Meta increasingly emphasises broad targeting, the effectiveness of [...]
It’s the second week of November, and Black Friday promotions are in full swing; emails, ads, organic posts. But, how many of these promotions are you actually paying [...]
Google’s new search feature, AI Overviews, has recently launched in Australia, transforming how we interact with search engines. With AI-generated summaries now appearing directly in search engine [...]
TikTok can be polarising. Those who use it, love it. Those who don’t often find it confusing or aren’t sure how it could fit into their social media [...]
We’ve been geeking out over our latest Audience Intelligence Reports which rolled out to our clients over the last two weeks. Separate from our monthly digital marketing [...]
When you think about it, Pinterest is not really a social media platform but more of a search engine. While it does allow users to follow and [...]
When a social media post starts gaining traction, you’ll often receive prompts from the platform encouraging you to reach a wider audience by boosting the post. A [...]
In our last article, we explored the rise of zero-click searches and its impact on how we find information online. This shift in user behaviour has also [...]
One of our biggest takeaways from State of Social 2024 was the evolution of zero-click searches and the impact it will have on the way we do [...]
Have you noticed a drop in engagement on your brand’s Instagram posts? Likes not flowing as much as what they used to? The good news is you’re [...]
Did you know that after approximately 4 exposures to your ad, your conversions can drop by almost half? As Meta increasingly emphasises broad targeting, the effectiveness of [...]
